Thursday, March 13, 2014

A Better Cooling Fan for PLA

You need lots of cooling air when printing with PLA in order to keep the plastic from moving around and deforming. I have a MendelMax 2.0 printer, as well as a Makerbot Replicator 2 (which I won). At first I wasn’t that excited about the Makerbot because I had heard about how it wasn’t a good design and had problems. Until, that is, I tried it. The Makerbot nearly always produced better prints than my MendelMax.

The Makerbot produces better prints in two ways: it has no Z artifacts that I can see, and it is amazing at handling overhangs and small features. It was a while before I realized that the secret to the overhangs was the choice of fan on the Makerbot. Unlike almost all FFF 3D printers on the market, the Makerbot doesn’t use a standard 40mm case fan. Instead, it uses a 50mm blower fan (more on this later).

My Journey

The MendelMax came with a single 40mm fan that mounted to the front. I was actually pretty happy with this fan at first. But then I found some designs were harder to print, and I read about Ohmeye’s use of two 40mm fans to increase the airflow.

http://ohmeye.com/2013/new-mendelmax2-fan-mounts/

So I designed my own version, which looked like this:

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
http://www.thingiverse.com/thing:139952

I was very happy with this design until my experience with a Makerbot Replicator 2 that I won in September 2013--it did a much better job ad made me realize there was much more room for improvement with my MendelMax 2.0. Since then I’ve been working on improving my MM 2.

I decided to try making a fan duct that would pressurize the air around the nozzle to provide even better cooling. I started out with a fairly small slot at the end, but not much air came out. I kept enlarging the hole until I ended up with this design:

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
http://www.thingiverse.com/thing:217208

The opening at the end of the duct is larger than I wanted. I wasn’t sure why the smaller slot didn’t work well, and then I noticed air was being blown back out of the fan around the outer ring. In other words, when I placed my hand near the fan (to the left of the fan in this picture), I could feel quite a bit of air hitting my hand. That meant more air was being blown back out than was going through the nozzle.

So how much of a difference does it make to have a fan duct instead of two fans? The photo below shows the difference, looking from the bottom of the parts. I printed the part on the left with my original two-fan setup, and the part on the right was printed with the fan duct plus an angled fan. You can see I got much better results replacing one of the fans with a ducted fan:

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

In other words, yes, good cooling really makes a difference, especially with the overhang in this design.

At this point I probably could have stopped. However I took a better look at the Replicator 2 and discovered they used a completely different type of fan. The fan they used is a centrifugal fan (also know as a blower fan or squirrel cage fan) instead of an axial fan. These fans seem to be much better at pressurizing the air, and therefore can provide a faster flow of air over the nozzle.

Here is the fan I purchased for my MendelMax:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00BKE445C/ref=oh_details_o06_s00_i00?ie=UTF8&psc=1.

This is a 24 V fan since the MendelMax uses 24 V for the heaters and fan.

The “Final” Design

I designed a new fan duct to use the centrifugal fan, and I decided to if this single ducted fan would be as effective as my two fans (with one being ducted). It was.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

I’ll have this design up on Thingiverse soon. Right now it’s not letting me publish a new thing because it keeps forgetting about the STL files that I’ve included. You can find the files here: http://www.thingiverse.com/thing:267212

3 comments:

  1. Awesome post! My first experience with 3D printing was with a Makerbot Replicator 2 at work and it still blows away my RepRapPro Mendel for printing small features and overhangs as you mentioned. I've tried a few quick fixes (higher CFM fans, fan ducts I found on Ihingiverse, etc.) with mixed results that never matched the Rep2: http://imgur.com/a/2SUMN

    The biggest improvement always seemed to be putting a big desk fan and pointing it right at the printer, but that's obviously not optimal. I'm quite curious now to try this on my Mendel, although I'll need to redesign the holder to fit the different style of X-axis carriage.

    ReplyDelete
  2. http://www.amazon.com/Brushless-Blower-50x50x15mm-Sleeve-bearing-Skywalking/dp/B00BKE27V0/ref=pd_sim_sbs_hg_1?ie=UTF8&refRID=1H2Y05MWW80DWTXY4BS3

    What about using 12volt blower fan instead of 24volt?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Also, this looks like it might work, and is a 24v fan...but since it uses inches in the description, I was not seeing it first off. The 2in x 2in is essentially 50mm...and since it is Amazon Prime eligible it might be a lot better than ordering from overseas: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00H8VV0XK/ref=oh_details_o00_s00_i00?ie=UTF8&psc=1

    ReplyDelete